SAU 6 Board — September 29, 2022

Regular meeting of the SAU 6 board (Claremont and Unity members). The board approved three sets of minutes going back to December 2021, heard the consultant hired to study SAU central-office staffing, set its budget calendar (October 27, December 1 and a final vote December 15), and heard that the auditor had asked to push Claremont's fiscal 2020 audit, due the next day, to the end of October. One member took part by video. Built from the recording, the posted agenda and the draft minutes. Timestamps link to the same moment in the Cablecast recording.

Body
SAU 6 Board (school administrative unit for the Claremont and Unity school districts), regular meeting
Date
Thursday, September 29, 2022
Start time
6:30 p.m. per the agenda (closing activities scheduled 8:00). Called to order at 0:00:32; the motion to adjourn came at 0:52:04, about 52 minutes later. The draft minutes give "6:30PM" and no adjournment time. No nonpublic session. Recording runs 0:52:24.
Location
Sugar River Valley Regional Technical Center, Claremont (agenda and minutes)
Recording
Cablecast: SAU 6 Board Meeting of 9/29/22 (runs 0:52:24; opens with pre-meeting conversation and ends at adjournment)
Minutes
draft SAU 6 School Board Meeting Minutes 9.29.22, "Submitted by Chelsea Weatherford", filed in the November 16 SAU 6 packet folder (flag 2) and approved at that meeting (November 16 page).
Board composition
Twelve members per the agenda: Marjorie Erickson (chair), Frank Sprague (vice chair), Michael Petrin, Shannon Popescu, Garry Bator, Rocco Ruggeri, Atonya Hart, Steven Horsky, Joshua Lambert, Bonnie Miles, Whitney Skillen, Heather Whitney. The minutes list Bator absent and Heather Whitney as both present and absent; Skillen took part by video (flag 1).

Participants

Everyone in the record. Names follow the dialogue file; where it says Unidentified, so does this table. Members the draft minutes list as present but who cannot be picked out on tape are listed with that note. Spellings from the agenda are used for names the tape does not carry.
NameRoleParticipation
UnidentifiedPresiding member at the openingCalled the meeting to order, asked for an acting secretary, and ran the agenda and minutes votes until the chair arrived. The dialogue file leaves this voice unnamed; the draft minutes say "Meeting called to order by Frank Sprague", the vice chair.
Marjorie EricksonSAU 6 ChairArrived during the superintendent's report ("So you've already done the minutes." at 0:14:38) and presided from there: consultant questions, budget calendar, audits, staffing, future items; confirmed merit pay for the superintendent review was discontinued. Identified in the dialogue file with medium confidence; never named on tape.
Steven HorskyBoard member (Claremont)Asked for separate minutes votes so he could abstain on April and June; questioned the COVID figures and the consultant's comparison states; proposed moving the budget meetings to October 27 and early December; asked about merit pay; moved adjournment.
Whitney SkillenBoard member (Claremont), by video"This is Whitney, and I. You probably can't see me." Asked the consultant how staff who fear retaliation could speak candidly. Said she would be away October 27. The minutes record her seconding adjournment. Identified with medium confidence (Heather Whitney not excluded outright).
Bonnie MilesBoard member (Claremont)Moved the June 16 minutes.
Joshua LambertBoard member (Claremont)Seconded the agenda ("Seconded by Josh"). The minutes also record him moving the December and April minutes.
Shannon PopescuBoard member (Unity)Seconded the June 16 minutes.
Frank SpragueSAU 6 Vice Chair (Claremont)Present per the minutes, which say he called the meeting to order and seconded the April minutes. The dialogue file does not attribute any row to him.
Michael PetrinBoard member (Claremont)Present per the minutes, which record him moving the agenda. The dialogue file attributes that motion ("For the motion to approve the agenda as a as presented." at 0:02:09) to Michael Tempesta, who is not a board member; see the method note.
Rocco Ruggeri; Atonya HartBoard members (Unity)Present per the minutes; not identified on tape.
Heather WhitneyBoard member (Claremont)The minutes list her among those present and again as absent (flag 2).
Garry BatorBoard member (Unity)Absent (minutes). Spelled "Garry Bator" in the agenda and minutes; the project roster carries "Gary Bader", unverified.
Michael TempestaSuperintendent, SAU 6Superintendent's report (FableVision, SB 420 special meetings in both districts, the staffing study, COVID numbers, staff shortages); staffing changes at the SAU office; said the superintendent had no dedicated administrative assistant "For at least 12 years or so".
Richard SeamanAssistant Superintendent for Finance, Operations and Human ResourcesProposed the budget calendar; reported the audit status and that Claremont had used almost all of its expiring Title II, III and IV money (flag 4).
William LupiniConsultant, SAU staffing study (remote)Former superintendent working with Anne Wilson (an Wilson in the transcript); document review and interviews; "we will not be attributing anything to any individuals in the report"; report due "first or second week of November ish".
UnidentifiedActing secretary; members asking questions; staff on remote audioThe roll call; board members' questions to the consultant, on the audit and on the ESSER-funded posting. None is named on tape.
(none)Citizens' comments"See any citizens? So I will close citizens comments." Minutes: "No citizens present".

Agenda

From the posted SAU 6 School Board Agenda 9.29.22, with dispositions from the recording and the draft minutes. Quoted agenda and minutes wording is marked as such.

Taken upItemAgenda text / disposition
0:00:32I. Call to Order and PledgeMinutes: "Meeting called to order by Frank Sprague".
0:00:58II. Secretary Roll CallAn acting secretary called the roll. Minutes: "Present: Marjorie Erickson, Frank Sprague, Michael Petrin, Shannon Popescu, Rocco Ruggeri, Atonya Hart, Steven Horsky, Joshua Lambert, Bonnie Miles, Whitney Skillen and Heather Whitney. Absent:Garry Bator, Heather Whitney".
0:01:49II.a Agenda: Amendments and Final ApprovalApproved as presented; vote at 0:02:14. Minutes: "Motion to approve agenda as presented by Michael Petrin; Seconded by Joshua Lambert; all in favor via voice vote".
0:02:21II.b Approval of previous meeting minutes: December 16, 2021, April 21, 2022, June 16, 2022Taken separately at Horsky's request. December 16 at 0:03:02; April 21 at 0:03:17 (Horsky abstained); June 16 at 0:03:50 (Miles moved, Popescu seconded, Horsky abstained). All voice votes (flag 3).
0:04:00II.c Citizens CommentsNone.
0:04:27III. Superintendent ReportFableVision; SB 420 special meetings; the staffing study; COVID; staff shortages.
0:15:10IV.a SAU 6 Consultant Review Discussion/UpdateWilliam Lupini by video. No action (flag 5).
0:27:22IV.b FY23 SAU 6 Budget TimelineAgenda says "FY23"; the budget in preparation is for the next fiscal year. Meetings set for October 27 and December 1, with final approval targeted for December 15 (0:34:50). By consensus; no recorded vote.
0:36:24IV.c Update of SAU 6 Financial Audits/GrantsSAU and Unity 2020 audits in draft; Claremont 2020 audit to be pushed to the end of October at the auditor's request (flag 4).
0:40:39IV.d SAU 6 Staffing UpdateChelsea Weatherford to assistant to the superintendent; a new part-time receptionist; a Claremont ESSER-funded assistant post.
0:47:25V. Future Agenda ItemsThe budget, the study report (a meeting tentatively on November 17), SAU policies to NHSBA for review, superintendent goal-setting.
0:52:04VI to VII. Other Business; ClosingHorsky moved to adjourn; second unidentified on tape; vote at 0:52:13. Minutes: "seconded by Whitney Skillen; all in favor via voice vote".

Discussion timeline

Chronological, from the dialogue CSV. Times are the start of the cited exchange, from the CSV's own second count. Hover over (or Tab to) a clipped cell for the full entry.

TimeTopicWhat was saidFlags
0:00:32Call to order; roll"I'd like to call this meeting of the saw six [SAU 6] board to order." "Are you acting Secretary tonight? I can be." The roll as transcribed is a series of "Here" answers, with "Miles" and "Whitney. Skilling." audible.OBSERVATION
0:01:49Agenda"I'm looking for a motion to approve or amend the agenda." The motion at 0:02:09 is labelled Michael Tempesta in the dialogue file; the minutes give it to Michael Petrin. Lambert seconded at 0:02:13.OBSERVATION
0:02:21Three sets of old minutes"We don't have them here, but we received them by email. The minutes from December 16th, 2021 April 21st, 2022. In June 16th, 2022." Horsky at 0:02:54: "I'd have to do them separately because I'd have to abstain from two votes." All three approved.OBSERVATION
0:04:27Superintendent's reportFableVision in both districts; SB 420 money "coming into both boards", with special meetings and "accountability plans for both saying how we're going to use the money". The staffing study at 0:07:14: an outside person "to measure all the things that we do and do an audit of the staffing that was requested".
0:08:39COVID and shortagesCase counts low; "no one is reporting it". Erickson at 0:10:54: "No staffing issues at the middle school?" Tempesta at 0:12:40: "it is now endemic time." At 0:14:06: "We still have a lot of ads. We don't have a lot of applicants. We're still short paraprofessionals."
0:14:38The chair arrivesErickson: "So you've already done the minutes." Reply: "Might even be done before you got here."OBSERVATION
0:15:22The staffing studyLupini: work "with the Collins Center"; "looking particularly at the saw [SAU] and whether you're appropriately staffed"; "two tracks", a document review and interviews; comparable districts in New Hampshire and perhaps Massachusetts or Maine; "a report in in early November". At 0:18:53: other issues such as special and vocational education will be shared as feedback.POSITIVE
0:20:34Candour of staffSkillen, by video: "How will you provide a safe space for the school staff to be candid about what is not working from their perspective?" Lupini at 0:20:57: "we will not be attributing anything to any individuals in the report." Skillen at 0:21:56: some teachers "have expressed not wanting to share feedback for any fear of retaliation".MEDIUM
0:22:23Comparisons; the productHorsky asked why Vermont was left out; Lupini agreed to consider it. Erickson at 0:23:54: "And so this the product then is a written report." Lupini: "And and a presentation."
0:27:22Budget calendarSeaman: last year's meetings on the third Thursdays of October, November and December; "we need to get it approved before we can finalize any of the budgets for the school districts"; "90% of the budget for the Saw is people". Tempesta at 0:30:13: October 20 collides with Claremont's special meeting. Horsky at 0:33:02 proposed early December. Settled at 0:34:50: "the 27th of October, the 1st of December, and then two weeks later, still targeting for a final approval on the 15th."POSITIVE
0:36:29AuditsSeaman: a draft of "the s a year [SAU] 2020" audit this week; "we'll be starting up on the 2020 audit for Claremont"; the auditor asks "that we push back the date for the Claremont audit, which was supposed to have been done by tomorrow to the end of next month", citing "the unexpected departure of two senior members" of the audit team and grant reconciliation. Fiscal 2022 still due "by the 15th of February".OBSERVATION
0:38:27Grants"we have been successful in utilizing, in Claremont, at least all of the title, except for, I think, about $10,000 of the title, two, three, and four funds." At 0:39:20: "we've met the required time frames as it relates to the to the grants." Unity's 2020 audit at 0:39:57: "I have it in final draft."OBSERVATION
0:40:39SAU staffingWeatherford moves to assistant to the superintendent; a new receptionist; the departure of Melissa Small, "a staple there forever". A member at 0:42:42 asked where money for an assistant-to-the-assistant-superintendent posting came from; Tempesta: a Claremont ESSER-funded post "Replacing Tammy Morse". At 0:45:35: the superintendent "has never had their own administrative" assistant "For at least 12 years or so".
0:47:25Future itemsTempesta at 0:49:18: "we have four saw six meetings" before December 15; "That's a year's worth in other years ago." Erickson at 0:50:04 on SAU policies: "I know we haven't done any in a long time."
0:50:26Merit pay; superintendent goalsHorsky asked whether the review process on merit pay was finalized; answer: "it's been discontinued." Erickson at 0:50:59: "I do believe we're supposed to meet with the superintendents sometime soon" for goal-setting.
0:52:04AdjournmentHorsky: "I would like to make a motion to adjourn this meeting." Second unidentified; voice vote at 0:52:13.MEDIUM

Items flagged for review

Flags are a reviewer's aid generated by comparing the meeting against the state and federal law in force on September 29, 2022. RSA 91-A and RSA 194-C:9 are cited from their 2022 codifications. They are not findings of violation, and nothing here is legal advice. Each flag cites the rule it rests on; where no verified rule applies, the flag says so and is recorded as an observation. 5 flags follow, ordered by severity.

MEDIUM A member took part by video, every vote was a voice vote, and the minutes record neither her remote attendance nor a reason

Skillen spoke by video at 0:20:34 ("You probably can't see me"). The minutes list her among those present and record her seconding adjournment, with no mention that she attended remotely. In the 2022 text of RSA 91-A:2, III(a), a member may participate other than in person "only when such attendance is not reasonably practical"; "Any reason that such attendance is not reasonably practical shall be stated in the minutes of the meeting"; and "All votes taken during such a meeting shall be by roll call vote." Every vote tonight (agenda at 0:02:14, three sets of minutes, adjournment at 0:52:13) was taken as "All those in favor?", and the minutes record each as a voice vote. Mitigation: the votes were uncontested and procedural, and a quorum was physically present by the minutes' count. The same pattern recurs at the November 16 SAU 6 meeting (November 16 page, flag 1), which grades it the same way.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, III (2022 codification; source note ends 2018, 244:1); RSA 91-A:1-a, VI(d) (a school administrative unit's board is a public body).

OBSERVATION The draft minutes list one member as both present and absent, record the late-arriving chair as present from the start, and reached the public share seven weeks later; the agenda reached it half an hour before the meeting

The roll in the minutes reads "Present: ... Whitney Skillen and Heather Whitney. Absent:Garry Bator, Heather Whitney". The chair arrived after the minutes votes (0:14:38), yet appears in the present list with no note, although the agenda itself says "Board Members who arrive after the meeting begins will be noted as “present” at the point in the agenda at which they arrive". RSA 91-A:2, II requires minutes to "include the names of members". The minutes do record a mover and seconder for each motion, and they name Frank Sprague as the member who called the meeting to order, which the recording does not settle.

The draft was created in the November 16 SAU 6 packet folder on November 16, 2022: the thirty-first business day after the meeting, counting Columbus Day, the biennial election day and Veterans Day out, against a requirement that minutes be "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting". The agenda's Drive copy was created at 6:00 p.m. on September 29, thirty minutes before the call to order. Drive created times date online posting, not the notice posted in public places or availability at the SAU office, so both are observations about online availability.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2022 codification: names of members; five business days); RSA 288:1 (legal holidays); draft SAU 6 School Board Meeting Minutes 9.29.22.

OBSERVATION Minutes of a December 2021 meeting were approved nine months later, from copies members said they did not have in front of them

At 0:02:21 the presiding member introduced the December 16, 2021, April 21, 2022 and June 16, 2022 minutes: "We don't have them here, but we received them by email." All three were approved by voice vote. Approval has no statutory deadline; what RSA 91-A:2, II requires is that minutes, draft or final, be "open to public inspection not more than 5 business days after the meeting". Whether the December and April drafts were available that quickly cannot be tested from here, because the district's online packet share begins in July 2022. A nine-month gap between a meeting and approval of its minutes means the public record of that meeting stayed in draft for most of a year. Recorded as an observation.

Sources: RSA 91-A:2, II (2022 codification).

OBSERVATION Claremont's fiscal 2020 audit, due under the district's own schedule the next day, was put back another month at the auditor's request

Seaman at 0:36:55: the auditor asked "that we push back the date for the Claremont audit, which was supposed to have been done by tomorrow to the end of next month", citing "the unexpected departure of two senior members" of the audit team and "the continuing effort that we have in reconciling our grant funds"; the fiscal 2022 audit would still be done by February 15, "which is really the most critical time frame for us to get on to so that we're back on to a normal audit." The SAU's 2020 audit arrived in draft this week and Unity's was "in final draft". The federal deadline and the severity of the backlog are analysed on the September 7 Claremont page, flag 1, where the finding sits. On the positive side, Seaman reported at 0:38:27 that Claremont had used all but about $10,000 of its expiring Title II, III and IV funds within the deadline, which answers the lapse risk raised on September 7.

Sources: the recording at 0:36:29 to 0:39:57; 2 CFR 200.512(a)(1) (2022 edition).

POSITIVE The SAU commissioned an outside review of its own staffing, heard the consultant in open session, and set a budget calendar with time to use the findings

The consultant described the method, the timetable and a promise of non-attribution to staff in public (0:15:22 to 0:24:20), and a member used the session to tell teachers watching that they could speak without fear of retaliation. The board then moved its budget meetings so the study could inform the SAU budget, setting a final vote for December 15 (0:34:50). RSA 194-C:9, I, as it read in 2022, required the SAU budget to be adopted "At a meeting held before January 1"; the calendar leaves a margin and three working sessions. No rule required an outside staffing review; commissioning one and hearing it in public is practice beyond the minimum. The report itself was presented on November 16 (November 16 page).

Sources: RSA 194-C:9, I (2022 codification; source 1996, 298:3; 2003, 279:1).

Appendix: source files

Official and public sources

Project files

Working files this page was built from. The dialogue file is linked; the others are not published with the page.

Laws and rules cited on this page